Showing posts with label interministerial meeting 2011. Show all posts
Showing posts with label interministerial meeting 2011. Show all posts

Tuesday, 6 August 2013

2014 Global Forum: A “meeting place” for people concerned about statelessness

In September 2014, Tilburg University and UNHCR will co-host the First Global Forum on Statelessness. Originally, when the idea of organising an event to mark the 60th anniversary of the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons was first conceived by the Statelessness Programme at Tilburg Law School, the vision was of a traditional academic conference. Around the world, individual scholars and research institutes have shown a growing interest in studying and discussing statelessness over the past decade. The channels for sharing and debating the findings of such research remain limited, however, as there have been no conferences, nor are there any journals, specifically dedicated to statelessness. As a result, information remains dispersed, as papers are published or presented in a wide variety of venues – i.e. in journals or at conferences focusing on related issues including migration, human rights, international relations, etc. While there have been numerous meetings in the last few years which focused on statelessness, these have tended to concentrate on convening only government representatives (e.g. 2011 UNHCR Ministerial meeting) or NGOs (e.g. annual UNHCR-NGO consultations, with the recent addition of a statelessness retreat). The initial ambition of the Statelessness Programme was to organise the equivalent global meeting for members of the university community in order to share research experiences and findings on statelessness, as well as start to plot out a research agenda for the future. Following discussions with UNHCR and the decision to form a partnership for this event, we set our joint sights a little higher…

 After lengthy consideration of the alternatives, the word ‘Forum’ was carefully chosen to describe the international conference that is now planned for September 2014 in the Hague. The idea is simple: to offer a meeting place where people who are concerned about statelessness can come together and share their ideas and experiences. This includes academics, governments, NGOs, legal practitioners, UN staff, journalists, community and faith-based groups and, those directly affected - stateless and formerly stateless people themselves. There will still be some of the familiar trappings of an academic conference, such as a number of keynote speeches on different aspects of statelessness research and policy by prominent international experts, the opportunity for academics to present and ask for feedback on a research paper they are preparing and the publication, after the event, of a book which offers a selection of some of the most current and cutting edge research in this field. But there will equally be opportunity for government representatives to present and discuss their policy experiences and for others engaged in addressing statelessness to share observations and ideas from their own work. The Forum will be flexible in terms of the way in which particular sessions are designed, depending on the envisaged topic, participants and desired outcome. This could mean panel debates, multimedia sessions, interactive workshops or other formats and we are keen to explore such ideas with any individual or organization that is interested in helping to shape part of the event with us. Moreover, in the spirit of the ancient Roman forum, or marketplace, the First Global Forum on Statelessness will also provide ample informal space for meeting, gathering and exchanging views, including through the inclusion of networking events as part of the programme.

"The daily suffering of millions of stateless people is an affront to humanity. The persistence of statelessness around the world is a challenge that requires a concerted international response. Building on the momentum of renewed international commitment to address statelessness, the First Global Forum on Statelessness presents an invaluable opportunity to bring together stateless people, policy makers, academics, NGOs and international organizations to come up with solutions to end statelessness.” - UNHCR High Commissioner António Guterres

 While the Forum aims to be flexible to accommodate the diverse backgrounds and styles of its participants, certain important parameters have nevertheless been set. To begin with, for this First Global Forum on Statelessness, the overarching topic of “New Directions in Statelessness Research and Policy” has been selected. We recognise and value the wealth of knowledge and experience that has amassed around the issue of statelessness, especially over the past few years. Now is the time to explore this collectively, in order to discover and share innovations that will help to ensure a more effective response to statelessness in the future, as well as to discuss the challenges that we still face and how to move forward. New research findings can help to feed into more effective policy, while policy innovations and obstacles may spark new research projects. Under this broad umbrella, the Forum will delve in particular into three themes which have also been set: Stateless Children, Statelessness and Security and Responses to Statelessness (a description of each theme can be found on the Forum website). Again, we are happy to discuss with anyone who is considering participating in the forum how their personal or organisational experiences with statelessness can be linked to one or more of these themes and help them to identify how their work or knowledge can best feed into the Forum. Our hope is that the exchange of information and the establishment of new contacts at the Forum will give a fresh boost to activities and collaboration in the field of statelessness.

 The call for presenters for the First Global Forum on Statelessness is now open. Proposals can be submitted using a simple application form which can be downloaded from the Forum website at www.tilburguniversity.edu/statelessness2014. The deadline for submissions is 1 December 2013. To first discuss ideas for a presentation, to propose a panel or workshop, or to be added to the mailing list for updates on the Global Forum, write to statelessness2014@tilburguniversity.edu.

Laura van Waas, Senior Researcher and Manager, Statelessness Programme

[This blog also appeared on the website of the European Network on Statelessness,  www.statelessness.eu]

Friday, 26 October 2012

An instant best practice: Philippines’ new Stateless Status Determination Procedure


The Philippines made history this week by becoming the first state in Asia to put a statelessness determination procedure in place. This move follows the country’s ratification, just over a year ago now, of the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and the pledge made at last December’s UNHCR High Level Meeting to proceed with establishing a procedure. The adoption of Department Circular No. 58 on “Establishing the Refugee and Stateless Status Determination Procedure” sets a good example, not only in the region, where protection frameworks for stateless people are largely absent, but also to countries in other parts of the world which acceded to the 1954 Convention but have yet to take this vital step in its implementation. There are currently 76 state parties to the 1954 Convention, but less than a dozen examples of dedicated statelessness determination procedures globally.

I was especially excited to hear of the new law passed in the Philippines because I was fortunate enough to have the chance to follow some of the preceding developments first hand. In late 2010, while I was working with UNHCR’s regional office in Bangkok, I had a wonderful, whirlwind 24 hour-trip to Manila, where I gave a presentation on international statelessness law to a room full of people drawn from different government agencies and civil society. Thanks to the amazing efforts of the UNHCR office in the Philippines and the incredible support and enthusiasm of key people within the Department of Justice to carry this issue forward, the decision to ratify the 1954 Convention was already pretty much in the bag. The purpose of the meeting was to ensure that the ratification and any steps that would subsequently be required to implement the treaty enjoyed the broadest possible support, from all relevant stakeholders. I remember very clearly the energy in the room and the overriding sentiment that it was a highly logical step for the country to become a state party: the Philippines was, after all, already a state party to the convention’s sister instrument, the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, so surely it made perfect sense to ratify the 1954 Convention in order to complete the protection framework. Moreover, the Philippines had actually signed the statelessness instrument back in 1955, they had simply “forgotten” to follow this up with ratification when interest in this convention temporarily lapsed. This line of reasoning is indeed compelling and suggests that it may be possible to make up the lost ground in terms of accessions to the 1954 Convention relative to the 1951 refugee convention, now that statelessness is again gaining momentum as an issue of international concern.

In late 2011, I crossed paths with a government delegation from the Philippines again, just as the instrument of accession to the 1954 Convention was being deposited with the UN Secretary General. This time, it was at a statelessness workshop and photography exhibition in Madrid, which coincided with a “study visit” from the Philippines Department of Justice, facilitated by UNHCR.  They had travelled to Spain (and subsequently to Hungary), with a view to learning about the operation of statelessness determination procedures. What is most commendable about the law which has now been passed establishing the Philippines’ Stateless Status Determination Procedure, is this: while clearly incorporating good practices drawn from Spain, Hungary and the handful of other countries where a procedure exists, the Philippines’ procedure has addressed some of the shortcomings that are found elsewhere. For instance, it has not mimicked Hungary’s restrictive approach of only accepting applications for stateless status determination from people already lawfully staying in the territory. Moreover, the Philippines’ law explicitly states that, following the lodging of an application for statelessness determination, “any proceeding for the deportation or exclusion of the Applicant and/or his or her dependents shall be suspended” and that an order may also be given to release the applicant from detention (section 7). The Philippines’ law can therefore be considered as something of an instant best practice, providing a more favourable regime than the handful of “older” statelessness specific procedures and following instead in the footsteps of other recently created mechanisms in Moldova and Georgia. It has evidently also drawn from the recent UNHCR guidelines on statelessness determination procedures and the status of a stateless person, reinforcing the approach that is recommended in these guidance documents.

Besides the aforementioned section on the question of deportation and detention, other noteworthy elements of the Philippines law include: a shared burden of proof whereby the applicant and the government protection officer “collaborate” to determine whether the person is stateless; a standard of proof that takes into account the difficulty of establishing beyond any doubt that the person is stateless and instead requires this to be established “to a reasonable degree”; an entitlement to legal counsel, to an interpreter, to access to UNHCR and to be interviewed (heard) during the procedure; an explicit right to residence for a person found to be stateless and his/her family members; and the right to receive a motivated decision in writing and to seek review of a negative decision. In addition, the law deals clearly and appropriately with the relationship between stateless and refugee status determination. Where it is discovered that “a refugee claim appears to exist” in relation to an applicant for stateless status, the investigation into possible refugee status takes priority and stateless determination is only picked up again if the person is found not to be a refugee or following cessation of refugee status. For good measure, the law also explicitly reaffirms that “in no case shall there be contact with the authorities of a foreign state [an important tool in stateless determination] where there is a claim of persecution” (section 31). Finally, with the entry into force of this law, the Philippines’ Refugee Protection Unit has been renamed to become the Refugee and Stateless Persons Protection Unit, in acknowledgement of the need to promote the visibility of both vulnerable groups.

There are, nevertheless, a few questions that the Philippines’ law does not address. Although it indicates that the nationality laws of a specific group of countries with which the applicant has a relevant link must be examined, and that the applicant has the obligation to submit “all relevant evidence reasonably available”, it does not detail which forms of evidence may be accepted. Nor does it suggest how such evidence should be weighed, if there is any contradiction, or what conclusions are to be drawn from the failure of a country to which the applicant has a relevant link to respond to questions regarding his or her nationality status. Furthermore, the law prescribes a 90-day timeframe for reaching a decision on an application for either refugee or stateless status – “unless there are reasonable grounds for an extended period”. While it is certainly commendable to aspire to achieve such quick decision-making – establishing a “fair, speedy and non-adversarial procedure” is the stated objective of the law – it remains to be seen whether this is a realistic goal in the context of stateless status determination and whether it will be possible for the applicant to establish his or her statelessness “to a reasonable degree” within this time. All of these procedural issues are, nevertheless, likely to be ironed out as the determination officers gain experience with the new procedure. The law provides sufficient flexibility for on the job learning and all of the most important elements in terms of guiding principles, procedural protections and the rights of the applicant are in place. I wish the officers of the newly renamed Refugee and Stateless Persons Protection Unit the best of luck with their work and I look forward to continuing to follow the Philippines’ journey into the field of statelessness in the years to come.

Laura van Waas, Senior Researcher and Manager, Statelessness Programme.

Monday, 1 October 2012

Campaign for statelessness conventions gains traction, at last


The ‘statelessness conventions’, two little-known instruments that have long floated somewhere on the periphery of international law, are finally starting to command the attention that they deserve...
Closely related to, yet not really part of, either refugee law or human rights law, the Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and the Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness did not initially make much of a splash after their adoption in 1954 and 1961 respectively. The 1954 Convention took twice the time to gather enough state parties to enter into force as compared to its sister instrument, the virtually identical 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. Meanwhile, the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness took a full twelve years to gather just six ratifications and enter into force. After this less-than-promising start, both conventions continued to lag far behind other international agreements in terms of accessions and remained woefully under-appreciated. And so it was with no false modesty or irony that the instruments were still being described as “orphan conventions” into the late 1990s. Recently, however, there has been growing interest in these two international agreements which are specifically designed to help states to protect stateless people and avoid cases of statelessness.

In fact, over the past decade or so, repeated calls have been made by a variety of international and regional bodies - including on numerous occasions by the UN General Assembly - for states to embrace the statelessness conventions. With this renaissance of interest in the issue and rediscovery of the conventions, accessions have also started to pick up significantly. This trend now looks set to continue as the campaign to raise awareness of and support for the statelessness convention starts to really gain traction, especially with regard to Europe. Already at the December 2011 Ministerial Meeting convened by UNHCR, over 30 states worldwide made pledges relating to accession to one or both conventions and many, including some European countries have already acted on these promises. Then, at a similar UN high level meeting dedicated to the Rule of Law, there were further encouraging signs, in particular the pledge by the Delegation of the European Union on behalf of the EU Member States. This included the explicit and concrete statement that “the EU Member States which have not yet done so pledge to address the issue of statelessness by ratifying the 1954 UN Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and by considering the ratification of the 1961 UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness” (pledge 4).

This recent EU pledge confirms the position of the statelessness conventions at the heart of the international legal framework for tackling statelessness – EU countries pledge to address the issue by signing up to these instruments. This sends a strong signal to governments elsewhere about the value of these conventions, regardless of their somewhat chequered history. A close inspection of how this statement has been formulated suggests a slightly stronger commitment to the 1954 convention, which serves as the foundation for identifying and protecting stateless people. This is perhaps unsurprising given that the European Union has already achieved near-universal accession to this instrument, with just a handful of states still needing to take action. Still, the promise that universal acceptance of the 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons in the European Union will be met is significant. The instrument is pivotal to the protection of non-refugee stateless people and once all EU member states become parties, this will help to raise the profile of statelessness in the region and may provide a new avenue for instigating a Europe-wide dialogue on the implementation of states’ obligations towards the stateless.

At the same time, it is also promising that EU member states have collectively pledged to “consider” acceding to the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness. It is true that Europe already has its own, relatively strong, regional framework for the coordination of nationality policy and the avoidance of statelessness – provided by the 1997 European Convention on Nationality, the 2006 Council of Europe Convention on the Avoidance of Statelessness in relation to State succession and a range of related recommendations. Yet, there are still numerous EU member states which have not adopted these regional standards. And even if they were embraced across Europe, the 1961 Convention remains an important counterpart for this framework at the global level. It contains highly similar safeguards for the avoidance of statelessness and even provides a stronger guarantee with regard to acquisition of nationality at birth where a child would otherwise be stateless. Therefore, by also committing to universal accession of this second instrument, EU member states send a strong message to - and set a good example for - countries elsewhere about taking and sharing responsibility for ensuring that no-one is left without a nationality in this day and age. It remains to be seen within what timeframe these pledges will become a reality.

Laura van Waas, Senior Researcher and Manager, Statelessness Programme

This blog also appears on the website of the European Network on Statelessness

Wednesday, 19 September 2012

GUEST POST: Taking stock of State pledges to tackle statelessness?

It is now just three months short of a year since UN High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres, hailed a “quantum leap” in global efforts to tackle statelessness at a Ministerial Meeting organised by UNHCR in Geneva to mark the 50th Anniversary of the 1961 Statelessness Convention. At this meeting 61 countries made statelessness-related pledges and 33 states committed to accede or take steps to accede to either or both conventions.

In the European context it is welcome that Bulgaria, Georgia, Moldova and Portugal have since ratified both the Statelessness Conventions. Some states are in the process of doing so or are taking other measures to improve the protection of stateless persons. However, a number of states who made pledges are yet to take any concrete action.

Moreover, despite the fact that soon almost all EU states will have ratified the 1954 Convention on the Status of Stateless Persons, only a small handful have in place dedicated and effective procedures for identifying stateless persons. Having such mechnanisms in place is a critical first step for states to comply with their obligations under the 1954 Convention and international human rights law.

Looking ahead, several upcoming dates in the international calendar provide an early opportunity for states and other stakeholders to take stock of progress in implementing state pledges to tackle statelessness, and to focus attention and renew effort where this has not happened.

The first such opportunity arises next week with the High-Level Rule of Law meeting during the General Assembly to be held in New York on the 24th September 2012.  This forum is clearly relevant because the rule of law is undermined when individuals are made stateless and denied full equality before the law as a result of discrimination or arbitrary decision making.

Refugees International is marking this occasion by issuing a public statement signed by dozens of NGOs (including the European Network on Statelessness) which urges member states to take advantage of pledge accession to the Statelessness Conventions, to introduce procedures to identify and protect stateless persons subject to their jurisdiction and to amend nationality laws that discriminate against women, children and specific populations based on ethnicity, religion, or other impermissible factors.

Later in the week the focus switches from New York to Geneva for the Committee on the Rights of the Child 2012 Day of General Discussion on 28 September which focuses on “The Rights of All Children in the Context of International Migration”.  This discussion day provides an important opportunity to raise concerns about childhood statelessness, to provide documentation to the Committee in the context of its review of reports by State parties to the Convention and to push for a General Comment on Article 7 on the Convention of the Rights of the Child (the right of every child to be registered and to acquire a nationality). UNHCR has produced a leaflet which explains the link between Article 7 and the 1961 Statelessness Convention.

The meeting of UNHCR’s Executive Committee early next month (1-5 October), also in Geneva, presents another forum for states to  critically review their progress in implementing the commitments they made at the Ministerial Meeting last year.

All these meetings also provide civil society with an invaluable opportunity to evaluate what this means for their own campaigning and awareness-raising efforts. The European Network on Statelessness is organising an event in Budapest on 19-21 November to bring together many of its new members from across Europe in order to plan coordinated action. With over 35 new members having joined since the Network’s launch in June, we hope to be increasingly better placed to make a telling contribution.

Chris Nash is International Protection Policy Coordinator at Asylum Aid and Coordinator of the European Network on Statelessness (ENS). For further information about the Network contact info@statelessness.eu This blog first appeared on the ENS website - to sign up for future ENS newsletter and blog updates visit http://www.statelessness.eu/sign-up

Wednesday, 7 December 2011

A little inspiration from the UNHCR interministerial meeting!

Today was the first day of the 2-day intergovernmental meeting at Ministerial level, organised by UNHCR in honour of the 60th anniversary of the 1951 Refugee Convention and the 50th anniversary of the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness. A good number of the statements made have talked about statelessness - an achievement that would have been unthinkable even a few years ago. For a little inspiration, here's the relevant statelessness extracts from the opening speeches by the High Commissioner for Refugees himself, Antonio Guterres and by US Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton...


Antonio Guterres:
Turning now to the problem of statelessness, I am particularly heartened with the impact that commemorations activities seem to have had so far on the thinking and practice of states. An estimated 12 million people live without a nationality worldwide – a number comparable to that of refugees. Many of them are deprived of some of their most basic human rights: they cannot get married legally, go to public schools, enrol in university, or get a job. They are unable to obtain drivers licenses, birth certificates for their children, or death certificates when their loved ones pass away.  

Despite the millions of persons affected by it, statelessness has long been neglected on the global agenda. But this now seems to be changing. Four states – Croatia, Nigeria, Panama and the Philippines – have acceded in 2011 to one or both of the two statelessness conventions. Serbia and Turkmenistan will be depositing instruments of accession at the Special Treaty Event this evening. I am pleased that many more states have indicated their intention to announce their accession during the next two days.

At the same time, several states are already amending their national legislation to prevent and reduce statelessness, for example by allowing both men and women to pass their nationality on to their children. Statelessness is now literally “on the map” everywhere, with no region untouched by progress.

UNHCR is particularly grateful to the many states who have become champions of statelessness, lending their support to our advocacy work to move forward in this area.

But together we must go beyond acknowledging the problems of stateless people. What they really need are solutions that enable them to secure a nationality and enjoy the full rights of citizens.

Hillary Clinton:
Today, 12 million people on this planet wake up every morning stateless, belonging to no country at all. Most of them are in developing countries without sufficient resources. And more than 40 million people are displaced around the world. The pledges we are all making today will be an important step in helping them build a better future.

Later, Acting Assistant Secretary Robinson from the State Department’s Bureau of Population, Refugees, and Migration will speak in some detail about the 28 pledges the United States is delivering. I would like to briefly mention one that is a particular priority for the United States, and for me personally. It concerns one of the major causes of statelessness, which is discrimination against women.

At least 30 countries around the world prevent women from acquiring, retaining, or transmitting citizenship to their children or their foreign spouses. And in some cases, nationality laws strip
women of their citizenship if they marry someone from another country.

Because of these discriminatory laws, women often can’t register their marriages, the births of their children, or deaths in their family. These laws perpetuate generations of stateless people who are often unable to work legally or travel freely. They cannot vote, open a bank account, or own property. They often lack access to health care and other public services. And without birth registration or citizenship documents, stateless children often cannot attend school.

In this compromised state, women and children are vulnerable to abuse and exploitation, including gender-based violence, trafficking in persons, and arbitrary arrest and detention. And that hurts whole societies—because when women are given the opportunity to participate equally, they contribute to their countries’ democratic governance, peace and stability, and economic development.

The United States has launched an initiative to build global awareness about these issues, and to support efforts to end or amend those discriminatory laws. We will work to persuade government officials and members of parliaments to change nationality laws that discriminate against women, to ensure universal birth registration, and to establish procedures and systems to facilitate the acquisition of citizenship for stateless persons.

I encourage other member states to join this effort. I am pleased that High Commissioner Guterres has signaled his support. And I encourage UNHCR to work with UN Women, UNICEF, UNDP, and other UN partners to achieve equal nationality rights for women.